Equity vs Debt Compounding

SIP vs. Fixed Deposit (FD) Calculator

Compare the wealth creation potential, inflation resilience, and tax efficiency of Mutual Fund SIPs versus guaranteed Fixed Deposits.

Yr
%
%
%

Clear Winner

Mutual Fund SIP

Generates ₹5,82,446 more wealth than FD.

SIP Performance

Total Value

₹23,23,391

Inflation Adjusted

₹16,46,987

FD Performance

Total Value

₹17,40,945

Inflation Adjusted

₹12,62,550

Detailed Comparison
Total Invested
₹12,00,000
₹12,00,000
Risk Score
Moderate to High
Very Low (Safe)
Taxation
LTCG @ 12.5%
As per Income Slab
Liquidity
High (No lock-in, T+1 days)
Moderate (Penalty on early withdrawal)

Advisor Note: While SIPs offer significantly higher wealth creation over 10 years, they carry market risk. FDs are completely safe but often fail to beat inflation. A balanced portfolio uses FDs for emergency funds (1-2 years of expenses) and SIPs for long-term wealth creation.

Key Differences: Equity SIP vs. Bank FD

FeatureMutual Fund SIPBank Fixed Deposit (FD)
Expected Returns12% – 15% CAGR (Market Linked)6.5% – 7.5% p.a. (Fixed / Guaranteed)
Tax Efficiency12.5% LTCG after ₹1.25L exemptionTaxed at full income slab rate (up to 30%)
Inflation ProtectionHigh (Delivers 6%–8% real return)Low to Negative after tax & inflation
Volatility / RiskModerate to High in short termZero principal volatility (DICGC Insured)

Frequently Asked Questions (SIP vs FD FAQ)

Why is SIP much more tax-efficient than FD for high earners?

FD interest is added directly to your income and taxed at your marginal slab (up to 30% + cess). Equity SIP gains held over 12 months enjoy a ₹1.25 Lakh tax-free exemption every year, and gains above that are taxed at only 12.5%.

When should I choose FD over SIP?

FD is ideal for your Emergency Fund (6 months living expenses), short-term goals (< 3 years), and capital preservation needs where capital loss cannot be tolerated.

How does rupee cost averaging benefit SIP investors?

When markets drop, your fixed monthly SIP buys more mutual fund units at lower prices. When markets rise, your units appreciate, averaging down your cost per unit automatically without timing the market.

What is an ideal allocation between SIP and FD?

A common guideline is the Rule of (100 minus Age) in Equities (via SIPs) and the remainder in Fixed Income/FDs, adjusting for individual risk appetite and financial commitments.